Log in or Sign up

Whiskey TalkBeer Single Barrel Bourbon - A new barrel!

Discussion in 'Whiskey, Wine & Other Booze' started by Gene, May 16, 2015.

Thread Status:: Not open for further replies.

Page 1 of 41

Gene Just happy to be here Contributor

Joined:

Mar 14, 2013

Likes Received:

72,244

Location:

North Jersey / NYC
Barrel details:

Gene said: ↑

Alright friends, I am finally back from Kentucky and ready to share the details.

First, a little background. My great friend of many years (Vercingetorix, AKA Joe) is getting married in the fall, and I have the tremendous honor of being his best man. He is a true lover of American whiskey - bourbon and rye alike - so it seemed just too obvious what we should do to celebrate. Joe, myself, and two other gentlemen (including njdc2) in his wedding party set out for Kentucky on Thursday, driving 11 hours before arriving in Louisville, in time for a little ‘whiskey palate calibration’ and dinner.

We arrived at 9:45AM the next morning at the Four Roses warehousing & bottling location in Cox’s Creek. We pulled into the lot just as Jim Rutledge was getting out of his car. He led us into their brand new barrel selection room, where the ten barrels were there waiting for our arrival. This new room was a nicer and more formal setting than the one we encountered last year, in which we tasted from a lone table just off the bottling line floor.

We chatted with Jim and had a little Q&A while things were being set up, and then went one-by-one getting our glasses filled with samples straight from the barrels. There’s nothing quite like those little bits of barrel char in the bottom of each glass to remind you you’re drinking right from the source.

We did a first pass of smelling and tasting, then a second pass, and then revisited some individual samples. I realized pretty quickly that we had a great overall line-up - last time we were able to eliminate at least 3-4 on the first pass, but this time it seemed like at least eight of the barrels were really solid. Jim agreed that he had trouble kicking any of the samples out of the mix outright. That said, out of this very good line-up, there were three that did stand out as having something special.

We talked through the differences between these three, tasting, smelling, and re-tasting. As we deliberated over the course of the first hour, we noticed how a little air and a little time affected the samples. The candied orange peel that I had originally noted in the one was fleeting; it had almost completely faded, leaving a whiskey that was, while delicious, somewhat unremarkable. The black cherry in another had started to give way to a more traditional barrel character, which wasn’t a bad thing, but it had lost some of its unique charm.

After all this time, one of these three favorites - an OBSK at 10 years and 8 months of age - was still as alluring as it had been on the first sip. The nose is char & spice all the way. On the palate, it has a distinctly rich mouthfeel, leading with that spice again, balanced by waves of caramelized sugar, molasses, and subtle suggestions of candied fruit. As you roll it over the tongue and swallow, these waves lead into this seemingly everlasting finish, easing out from brown sugar to the slightest hint of ginger right at the end. I could drink this stuff all day.

Bottling will take place next month, and then the bottles will be available once they get to our partner out in California. We’re selling these through a different retailer this time, so the process will be a little different but should still be easy enough. I’ll follow up when we have more info. We are hoping to do the Barrel #003 pick as soon as October, so there will be more info on that in the coming months as well!

Click to expand...

Original background on this pick:

I'll be returning to Bardstown this Friday - so, I figured, if I'll be in the neighborhood anyway, why not go ahead and swing by Four Roses and taste through another suite of barrels?

It's been about a year since we selected barrels 001 & 002, and so while the official barrel selection committee (AKA Michigan and co.) are indeed working on planning our next OFFICIAL pick, I figured we could all use some more of that tasty barrel-strength juice, particularly as rumors swirl about the old stock on certain recipes running dry.

(Seriously, I'll be out there for other reasons, so this just seemed like a good opportunity to get us some more delicious bourbon. This will not be the official barrel #003 pick - more info on that TBA soon, hopefully.)

So, I wanted to get a thread going for a few reasons:

Gather your thoughts on flavor preferences (high-rye with interesting/fruity/spicy notes seemed to be the prevailing opinion last time).

Extend an invitation: If anyone in the area tastes bourbon often and wants to join us at the Four Roses warehouse & packaging facility on Friday morning to help with the tasting and selection process, please send me a message ASAP!

I'll use this thread to fill everyone in on the selection process, the characteristics of the barrels, and eventually the availability of bottles.

So, first thing's first - you have the opportunity to influence the pick here, so what characteristics do you guys seek out in a Four Roses private selection at barrel proof?
Click to expand...
Last edited: Jun 6, 2016

Gene, May 16, 2015

#1

drbenzo, CharlieMurphy, ABSTRACTlegend and 57 others like this.
stxSS07

Joined:

Apr 15, 2013

Likes Received:

53,460

Location:

South Chi-Burbs, IL

IN.

Unless I forget to buy it again.

Gimmie dat mallow and burn and maybe some fhruit or something. I dunno just pick one that tastes good.

stxSS07, May 16, 2015

#2

BusinessSloth, pgh_penguins, pdurrrr and 8 others like this.
HeadHunter

Joined:

Oct 14, 2013

Likes Received:

8,046

The Q recipes are the new waelzbro. Should definitely get one of those for maximum trade value.

HeadHunter, May 16, 2015

#3

thebandit1 likes this.
MikeG

Joined:

Oct 8, 2013

Likes Received:

21,458

Location:

Brooklyn, NY

In. Definitely interested in the E high rye mashbill. Q or K yeast.

MikeG, May 16, 2015

#4

waltersrj, Etan and thebandit1 like this.
Gene Just happy to be here Contributor

Joined:

Mar 14, 2013

Likes Received:

72,244

Location:

North Jersey / NYC

MikeG said: ↑

In. Definitely interested in the E high rye mashbill. Q or K yeast.
Click to expand...

I assume by "high rye mashbill" you mean "B," yes?

Gene, May 16, 2015

#5

BusinessSloth, GoodDon, CheapBeerBuzz and 8 others like this.
thebandit1

Joined:

Oct 9, 2013

Likes Received:

82,590

Location:

Denver CO

thebandit1, May 16, 2015

#6

KevyWevy, BusinessSloth, gregkoko and 8 others like this.
Espeer

Joined:

Mar 17, 2014

Likes Received:

2,999

Location:

Richmond, VA

Awesome. Everything I read about tb001 sounded great, so something similar? Gonna try real hard not to miss it this time! Thanks!

Espeer, May 16, 2015

#7
tinypyramids

Joined:

Oct 30, 2013

Likes Received:

3,327

Location:

Chicago, IL

both picks last time were super good so i trust the judgement of Gene and the community at large.

tinypyramids, May 16, 2015

#8
MikeG

Joined:

Oct 8, 2013

Likes Received:

21,458

Location:

Brooklyn, NY

Gene said: ↑

I assume by "high rye mashbill" you mean "B," yes?

Click to expand...

Yeah sorry, too much Sazerac Rye 6-year last night

MikeG, May 16, 2015

#9
bmh_the_1legend

Joined:

Oct 7, 2013

Likes Received:

19,765

Location:

Roanoke, VA

In, as long as my dumbass remembers to get one this go round!

bmh_the_1legend, May 16, 2015

#10

dontdrinkbeer likes this.
Hookemhops13

Joined:

Jun 27, 2014

Likes Received:

17,615

In!

Not sure what the previous picks were but I lean B mash bill with V or O yeast. harrymel sent me samples of all ten so after I taste through them I will update my opinion.

Hookemhops13, May 16, 2015

#11
TalkBeerJesus

Joined:

Apr 18, 2013

Likes Received:

1,784

Location:

Backfat's Apartment

IN!

TalkBeerJesus, May 16, 2015

#12
Ratman

Joined:

Oct 1, 2013

Likes Received:

32,824

Location:

NM

IN!!

Ratman, May 16, 2015

#13
lazerviking

Joined:

Sep 30, 2013

Likes Received:

55,170

Location:

~~

This makes me so happy. Also a big fan of the Q yeast, but understand if that's hard to come by. I love both recipes, but probably have a slight preference for the B recipe.

lazerviking, May 16, 2015

#14
SirDickButts

Joined:

Aug 28, 2014

Likes Received:

12,092

Location:

Outer Space

IN! and OBSO, plz.

SirDickButts, May 16, 2015

#15
Etan

Joined:

Apr 13, 2013

Likes Received:

4,649

Location:

Madison, Wisconsin

B mash, Q or V yeast is my 2cents.

Etan, May 16, 2015

#16

MikeG and lazerviking like this.
elkhunter36

Joined:

Jun 25, 2013

Likes Received:

40,212

Location:

Glendale, WI

In!

elkhunter36, May 16, 2015

#17
HeadHunter

Joined:

Oct 14, 2013

Likes Received:

8,046

And if it wasn't obvious, I'm in. Trust your judgment on this. I would have not thought of going with OESO or OBSQ last time and it turned out great.

HeadHunter, May 16, 2015

#18

Lognar likes this.
waltersrj

Joined:

Apr 14, 2013

Likes Received:

4,149

Location:

Portland, OR

OESO or OESQ
Honestly I'll buy whatever you pick lol.

waltersrj, May 16, 2015

#19

cparles likes this.
match1112

Joined:

Apr 11, 2013

Likes Received:

29,197

HOO-AH!

match1112, May 16, 2015

#20

mixed_master7, stxSS07 and Fingolfin like this.

(You must log in or sign up to reply here.)

Page 1 of 41

Thread Status:: Not open for further replies.