Quantcast

US - New England Hill Farmstead thread

Help Support Talkbeer:

Joined
Jul 29, 2015
Messages
95
Location
CT
Popped a George on New Year's Eve, it was very nice, but if you're looking for another VT brown ale to crush on Whetstone Station's Brown Paper Bag is pretty alright and they've got bottles of 3F Golden Blend available for consumption as of this past weekend too. Drank that and a S&S #1 with my brunch on Saturday, tough to decide which was the highlight.
 
Joined
May 20, 2015
Messages
149
Acurtis sent me a PM about what he tasted in his bottle(s) and instead of just writing back a PM I will just post it here as this kind of info is probably good for everyone. First if people have issues then I am always happy to hear about them either through pm on this site or through my email rwitter at gmail.com. These could be any issue ranging from beer our even poor experience at the brewery and I can promise you I will always do my best to address them.

On the issue of infection. When speaking understand I am speaking about what we do as I have witnessed it during my time here. Before we bottle clean beer we plate the beer. Plating involves using a medium which prohibits the growth of yeast and allows the growth of bacteria. This allows us to see if their is any possible beer spoiling bacteria in the beer. After bottling we plate again. All beer has to pass these plates to be bottled and has to pass the second plate to be released. We also store bottles in a library both at normal conditions and at high temps to accelerate aging. When a complaint such as his comes forward I grab bottles from both libraries and we taste. We did this yesterday with the Earl. We tasted nothing off in the beer what so ever. We plated again as well. The beer is not infected. What I think he is tasting based on his description to me is oxidation. The first earl and George runs showed very high levels of DO vs our standard beer and with the meheen we are always vigilant in our mission to get lower DO and a longer lasting product. We have already made a number of changes to the process which have provided us with good results. As we use it more we learn about it more and we will keep on striving to improve and chase perfection.

The term infection can be a powerful one and for that reason I think people should be careful when using it. Very easy for a game of telephone to spread around and misinformation to come about. Acurtis is you bought all that earl at the same time and have any left I would be interested in trying one from your case to see how it matches up with the two we tried yesterday. Hopefully this info is of help.
 
Joined
Mar 28, 2015
Messages
1,311
Location
Rhode Island
Acurtis sent me a PM about what he tasted in his bottle(s) and instead of just writing back a PM I will just post it here as this kind of info is probably good for everyone. First if people have issues then I am always happy to hear about them either through pm on this site or through my email rwitter at gmail.com. These could be any issue ranging from beer our even poor experience at the brewery and I can promise you I will always do my best to address them.

On the issue of infection. When speaking understand I am speaking about what we do as I have witnessed it during my time here. Before we bottle clean beer we plate the beer. Plating involves using a medium which prohibits the growth of yeast and allows the growth of bacteria. This allows us to see if their is any possible beer spoiling bacteria in the beer. After bottling we plate again. All beer has to pass these plates to be bottled and has to pass the second plate to be released. We also store bottles in a library both at normal conditions and at high temps to accelerate aging. When a complaint such as his comes forward I grab bottles from both libraries and we taste. We did this yesterday with the Earl. We tasted nothing off in the beer what so ever. We plated again as well. The beer is not infected. What I think he is tasting based on his description to me is oxidation. The first earl and George runs showed very high levels of DO vs our standard beer and with the meheen we are always vigilant in our mission to get lower DO and a longer lasting product. We have already made a number of changes to the process which have provided us with good results. As we use it more we learn about it more and we will keep on striving to improve and chase perfection.

The term infection can be a powerful one and for that reason I think people should be careful when using it. Very easy for a game of telephone to spread around and misinformation to come about. Acurtis is you bought all that earl at the same time and have any left I would be interested in trying one from your case to see how it matches up with the two we tried yesterday. Hopefully this info is of help.
This is great, thank you for sharing. I think you guys could teach Goose Island a few things.
 

Os

Joined
Apr 5, 2013
Messages
7,184
Location
NJ
Acurtis sent me a PM about what he tasted in his bottle(s) and instead of just writing back a PM I will just post it here as this kind of info is probably good for everyone. First if people have issues then I am always happy to hear about them either through pm on this site or through my email rwitter at gmail.com. These could be any issue ranging from beer our even poor experience at the brewery and I can promise you I will always do my best to address them.

On the issue of infection. When speaking understand I am speaking about what we do as I have witnessed it during my time here. Before we bottle clean beer we plate the beer. Plating involves using a medium which prohibits the growth of yeast and allows the growth of bacteria. This allows us to see if their is any possible beer spoiling bacteria in the beer. After bottling we plate again. All beer has to pass these plates to be bottled and has to pass the second plate to be released. We also store bottles in a library both at normal conditions and at high temps to accelerate aging. When a complaint such as his comes forward I grab bottles from both libraries and we taste. We did this yesterday with the Earl. We tasted nothing off in the beer what so ever. We plated again as well. The beer is not infected. What I think he is tasting based on his description to me is oxidation. The first earl and George runs showed very high levels of DO vs our standard beer and with the meheen we are always vigilant in our mission to get lower DO and a longer lasting product. We have already made a number of changes to the process which have provided us with good results. As we use it more we learn about it more and we will keep on striving to improve and chase perfection.

The term infection can be a powerful one and for that reason I think people should be careful when using it. Very easy for a game of telephone to spread around and misinformation to come about. Acurtis is you bought all that earl at the same time and have any left I would be interested in trying one from your case to see how it matches up with the two we tried yesterday. Hopefully this info is of help.
you sir, are getting a hug next time I see you!
 
Joined
Mar 28, 2015
Messages
1,311
Location
Rhode Island
Is there really an infection problem with bcbs or is this just run of the mill neckbeard stupidity? I assumed the latter...
Is there really an infection problem with bcbs or is this just run of the mill neckbeard stupidity? I assumed the latter...
I think you're probably right. I didn't love the BCBCS I opened, but I wouldn't have called it an infection.

My main point was that HF quality control is second to none.
 

Gene

Just happy to be here
Joined
Mar 14, 2013
Messages
4,915
Location
North Jersey / NYC
This is great, thank you for sharing. I think you guys could teach Goose Island a few things.
Is there really an infection problem with bcbs or is this just run of the mill neckbeard stupidity? I assumed the latter...
I think you're probably right. I didn't love the BCBCS I opened, but I wouldn't have called it an infection.

My main point was that HF quality control is second to none.
Infection or otherwise, this kind of transparency and open communication is an ideal model for all breweries companies and people to follow.
 
Joined
Oct 3, 2013
Messages
1,939
Location
Sleepy, NY
Agreed. Just wondering how it's possible for an infection to take hold in a 14% abv beer a month after it was bottled without GI first seeing the amount of bacteria necessary for this to be true... but I guess this is the wrong thread for that. Just curious.
 
Joined
Dec 11, 2014
Messages
2,266
Location
Bubbling In the Cut like Iodine
rwitter this question may be more for Shaun than for you since it was before you joined the team, but perhaps you can shed some light. If not maybe I will get a shot to ask Shaun on Friday if he is around.

Was the plating and testing protocol the same when M&C4 was released? If so, did things check out at test intervals, only for bottles to see a latent infection after release? This is not to imply anything or undermine the protocol if it was in place at the time- more so to help me understand if there is still some margin of potential susceptibility to infection despite a beer passing the tests.

Also, I only have anecdotal experience saying that at least some of those bottles were infected. I could be wrong- sure tasted soured.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Apr 10, 2013
Messages
2,464
Location
NYC
rwitter this question may be more for Shaun than for you since it was before you joined the team, but perhaps you can shed some light. If not maybe I will get a shot to ask Shaun on Friday if he is around.

Was the plating and testing protocol the same when M&C4 was released? If so, did things check out at test intervals, only for bottles to
see a latent infection after release? This is not to imply anything or undermine the protocol if it was in place at the time- more so to help me understand if there is still some margin of potential susceptibility to infection despite a beer passing the tests.

Also, I only have anecdotal experience saying that at least some of those bottles were infected. I could be wrong- sure tasted soured.
Same for BA Everett. That stuff poured out like cough syrup.
 
Joined
Jul 24, 2013
Messages
7,678
Location
TalkBeer.com
Not really a question for Ryan as it doesn't relate to any HF beers specifically, just a general question for anyone with commercial brewing experience, I guess.

The description Ryan provides above makes a lot of sense for tracking a beer "being infected" overall. E.g., this is going to catch any beer that has an undesirable culture picked up during fermentation, barrel aging, conditioning, or overall in the packaging process (e.g., a contaminated line, or whatever). I hope a lot of large breweries do things like this!

However, "bottle variation" is a real thing, is it not? I'm going to use a terrible homebrewing analogy - say you're bottling off a beer in previously used bottles - you could have a little bit of clingy bacteria left from a previous beer in that bottle - maybe you didn't clean it well enough. Or maybe you dropped one of your bottle caps on the floor in the bottling process, it was contaminated, and then you used it. Either way - your end result, you have a ton of bottles of completely A-OK beer and a bottle or two that are all kinds of messed up.

Obviously, using a mechanized filler, bottles off a pallet straight from the manufacturer, brand new caps directly from a manufacturer, etc. is going to minimize these kinds of risks. I'm curious to what degree these risks are minimized - seems like a lot of people toss out "bottle variation" as a catchall thing for even relatively fresh beers that taste different. Obviously, there's a trillion other factors here that I'm ignoring - for example, differences in storage conditions are likely to be much more important on a bottle tasting different than something like this happening, different bottling runs being different batches, yaddah yaddah.

But can it happen? How often could it? (Yes - I know the answer depends on the infrastructure that a brewery's using - I'm just curious if it's reasonable to expect that maybe out of a batch of beer HF releases, there's a bad bottle in there somewhere!)
 
Joined
Sep 12, 2014
Messages
88
With the new tasting room - should i expect to wait outside on Saturday? wanna make sure i'm dressed appropriately as i know its gonna be freezing this week
 

Latest posts

Top